A table with scissors, ribbon and presents wrapped in fabric, a lit Christmas tree glowing behind
Photo: Anastasia Shuraeva / Pexels

In our experience, the Christmas Eve activities that work best with small children follow one shape: get them outside in the morning, keep the early afternoon quiet, spend the late afternoon on one proper activity, eat early, then run the rituals slowly enough that bedtime arrives on its own. Screens go off an hour before lights out.

That is the whole plan. The rest of this page lays the day out in rough hours for a household with children somewhere between three and eight, flags the parts that reliably go wrong, gives the version for the year nobody has any energy, and then deals with bedtime, which is the actual problem and deserves to be treated as one. Families do this day in a hundred different ways, so take what fits and leave the rest.

What does the day look like, hour by hour?

Loosely, and with every time negotiable.

Morning: outside. A walk, a playground, a lap of the block to look at other people’s decorations. The goal is simple: spend the energy early, while it is useful, rather than at nine at night when it is not. If the weather is impossible, a dance party in the living room counts.

Lunch, then a quiet hour. Children who still nap should nap, even if they insist they are too excited. Older ones get a quiet hour with a book or a film. Grown-ups get to sit down, which may not happen again until tomorrow.

Mid-afternoon, around three: the one proper activity. In our experience this is the slot that goes wrong most often: excitement peaks just as energy dips. Plan one thing and do it properly. A Christmas scavenger hunt takes twenty minutes to set up and half an hour to play. Baking the cookies for tonight is another good choice, because it creates the evening’s ritual as well as filling the afternoon. A round of pen and paper Christmas games works with any number of cousins.

Late afternoon, around four: the five minute thing. Something short and funny to bridge to dinner, such as the Christmas alphabet, where each person says a Christmas word for the next letter.

Early dinner, around five thirty. Earlier than usual. A late, rich dinner followed by a plate of cookies is how a household ends up with a small person wide awake at ten.

Six thirty onward: the rituals, slowly. This is where the evening’s traditions go: putting out the plate, reading a story, hanging the stockings, whatever your house does. The trick is pace. Each one should take longer than it needs to. If you leave cookies out, why we leave cookies and milk for Santa has a few ways to stretch that one into twenty minutes, including the carrot and the note.

Bath, teeth, story, bed. In that order, the same order as every other night. More on this below.

Which parts reliably go wrong?

Three, in our experience.

The three o’clock slump. Excitement plus tiredness plus sugar. The fix is the one planned activity, started before the slump rather than during it.

Too much, too late. Sweets after five, a film that ends at eight, and a second round of presents from a visiting relative. Any of them alone is fine. All three together is a late night.

The threat. At some point in the evening, somebody, possibly a grandparent, will say that Santa does not come to children who are awake, or who are naughty. We would gently steer away from it. It turns the one day of the year that is meant to be pure good news into leverage, and in our experience a small child told that sleep is a condition of Christmas can lie there rigid with worry about failing it. The 2024 review by Setoh, Low, Heyman and Lee in Current Directions in Psychological Science separates shared fantasy figures, which families enjoy together, from false threats used to control behavior, which are the category with the worrying correlates. Those links come mostly from correlational studies, so they are a reason for caution rather than proof of harm. Santa on Christmas Eve belongs firmly in the first. If you need a line, “he comes when everyone is asleep, including us” is true to the story and threatens nobody.

What is the low-energy version?

For the year when everybody is sick, or the house is full, or you are simply spent:

  • Morning: one walk, however short.
  • Afternoon: a Christmas film, with everyone on the sofa under the same blanket.
  • Around four: one five minute game.
  • Dinner: whatever is easiest. Toast is dinner.
  • Evening: plate out, one story, bed.

That is a complete Christmas Eve. Nobody at school in January will ask what you did, and the child will remember the blanket.

Why is bedtime the real problem, and what helps?

Because, in our experience, the one night a child most wants to fall asleep quickly is the night they are least able to.

Some numbers help set expectations. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine’s 2016 consensus statement, endorsed by the American Academy of Pediatrics, recommends 10 to 13 hours in every 24 for children aged three to five, including naps, and 9 to 12 hours for children six to twelve. A child who gets a little less tonight is going to be fine; the recommendation is about regular sleep, not one night. It does suggest that a very late night and a very early morning will produce a tired, overwhelmed child by Christmas lunch, which is worth planning around.

What helps, based on the AAP’s general sleep advice on HealthyChildren.org:

Keep the routine. The AAP recommends a consistent routine such as “brush, book, bed.” Christmas Eve is the night to follow it exactly, because familiarity is calming when everything else is not.

Screens off an hour before bed. The AAP advises turning off all screens at least 60 minutes before bedtime. This includes the film, so start it earlier.

Keep the room cool and dark. The same page suggests 68 to 72 degrees Fahrenheit for children’s rooms.

Allow awake-in-bed. Our own view: a child who cannot sleep can read by a small light, or listen to a story, as long as they stay in bed. The goal is rest, not a battle. Most fall asleep mid-page.

It is also, pleasingly, the oldest part of the Christmas Eve story. The poem first printed in the Troy Sentinel in 1823 begins with the household already in bed: “The children were nestled all snug in their beds, / While visions of sugar plums danc’d in their heads.” Nobody in the poem is lying awake listening for hooves. Which is to say, even in the most famous Christmas Eve ever written, the adults had to get the children to sleep before anything else could happen.

One more idea for the four o’clock gap

If a phone is already out, Xmas Naughty Or Nice Scanner fills five minutes nicely. Point it at a relative and it draws a candy-cane frame, runs a sweep of light and unrolls a made-up verdict on a ribbon, out loud, which is funnier in a room full of relatives than anything typed into a box. Nothing about anybody is examined, and the best version is the one where the children scan the grown-ups. It is a small one-time purchase on iPhone. If you would rather not use a phone at all, the naughty or nice list checker on this site does the same joke in a browser, lands every verdict on the nice side, and costs nothing.

Sources