St. Nicholas Day is December 6, the feast of a fourth-century bishop of Myra, a town in what is now Turkey. The best-known St. Nicholas Day tradition is a shoe or stocking left out the night before and found the next morning with something small inside: a clementine, a few chocolate coins, a note.
The rest is a surprisingly thin paper trail. Almost nothing about the real man can be confirmed, the most famous story about him reached most readers through a collection compiled about nine centuries after he died, and the shoe custom is documented in the Netherlands from the fifteenth century. Here is what is known, what is legend, and how a family could keep the day without buying anything.
Who was Saint Nicholas, as far as anyone can tell?
Very little is certain, and the honest sources say so.
The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1911, hardly a skeptical publication, puts it bluntly: “there is scarcely anything historically certain about him except that he was Bishop of Myra in the fourth century.” It gives his death as December 6, in either 345 or 352, which is why the feast falls on that date. It notes that the colorful life stories, the childhood in Patara, the imprisonment under the emperor Diocletian, the appearance at the Council of Nicaea, were first written down in Greek in the tenth century, and it doubts even the Nicaea story, because his name is missing from the old lists of the bishops who attended.
So there was a bishop called Nicholas, he lived in the fourth century, and people remembered him strongly enough to keep telling stories about him for centuries before the versions we have were written down. That is the whole biography.
Where does the gift-giving come from?
From a legend, and it is a good one.
The version most people know comes from The Golden Legend, a collection of saints’ lives compiled by Jacobus de Voragine, archbishop of Genoa, around 1275, and translated into English by William Caxton in 1483. In it, a neighbor of the young Nicholas has fallen into poverty and has three daughters he cannot afford to marry off. Nicholas, in Caxton’s words, “threw by night secretly into the house of the man a mass of gold wrapped in a cloth.” He does it three times, once for each daughter. On the third night the father stays awake, follows him into the street and recognizes him, and Nicholas makes him promise to tell nobody.
Every piece of the later Santa is sitting in that story in some form: the gift, the night, the secrecy, the giver who does not want to be seen. Whether it happened is unknowable. Caxton’s source itself says the legend came from Greek writers, and none of them was writing in Nicholas’s lifetime. But it explains why this particular saint, out of hundreds, became the one who brings presents.
What happened to his body?
Here, for once, there is a document.
In 1087, sailors and merchants from Bari, in southern Italy, landed at Myra, broke into the tomb and took the bones home. An anonymous Greek account of the raid, translated in the Internet Medieval Sourcebook at Fordham University, names two priests on the expedition and records the relics entering Bari on May 9. They are still in the basilica of San Nicola there, and the Catholic Encyclopedia says plainly that the merchants “stole his body,” which is not how churches usually describe their own relics.
Then, in December 2017, the University of Oxford radiocarbon dated a fragment of hip bone held in a relic collection in the United States and venerated as St. Nicholas’s. As Archaeology magazine, published by the Archaeological Institute of America, reported, it came back as fourth century, the right period. That does not prove the bone was his. The magazine notes that hundreds of fragments around the world carry his name and that tests on relics usually show them to be younger than thought, which is what made this one news. It only means this bone could have been his, which is more than most relics can say.
What are the St. Nicholas Day traditions?
The Catholic Encyclopedia describes Nicholas, in Germany, Switzerland and the Netherlands, as the secret giver of gifts to children on December 6, which is the Golden Legend story turned into a household custom. The best documented is the Dutch one.
According to the Meertens Instituut, the folklore and language institute of the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences, the custom of putting out a shoe goes back to the fifteenth century. Then, children from poor families could leave their shoes in the church on December 5, wealthy citizens filled them, and the contents went to the poor the next day. Today Dutch children put a shoe by the fireplace or the heater, often with something in it for Sinterklaas’s horse, sing a song, and find a small treat in the morning. A bag of chocolate coins, the institute’s researcher points out, is already a present in its own right. The cookies-and-milk custom may have a root here too, which is traced in why we leave cookies and milk for Santa.
Beyond that, customs vary enormously by country, region and family, and many of the specific ones you will read about online are hard to trace to anything written down. We have kept to the ones with a source.
How did St. Nicholas turn into Santa Claus?
In outline: American writers in the early nineteenth century reworked him and moved his visit from December 6 to Christmas Eve. The Catholic Encyclopedia already noted in 1911 that in the United States he had become identified with Santa Claus, who comes on Christmas Eve instead.
The American part of that story is better documented than the medieval part, and it runs through a short 1821 poem and the 1823 “A Visit from St. Nicholas.” That history, including where the idea of a list of good and bad children first appears in print, is in how Santa knows if you have been naughty or nice, and the red coat has its own page: why Santa wears red.
How could a family keep St. Nicholas Day?
Here is our suggestion, offered as one family’s idea rather than a rule. Nobody has to add another date to December.
- The shoe. On the evening of December 5, everyone puts one shoe by the door. In the morning there is a clementine in each, or a chocolate coin, or a handwritten note. It costs almost nothing, it takes two minutes, and it starts the Christmas season gently, nearly three weeks before the big night.
- The secret gift. In the spirit of the three bags of gold, the household does one kind thing for someone in secret: a note through a neighbor’s door, a drawing left for a grandparent, a coffee paid for. The rule is that nobody finds out who did it.
- The story. Tell the dowry legend at dinner, in your own words, as a story about a man who liked giving more than being thanked. Children tend to find the chase in the street the best part.
What we would leave out is any version where the shoe stays empty because somebody misbehaved. The oldest form of the custom on record is about filling shoes for children who had nothing, which is a better tradition to inherit.
A small joke for later in the month
St. Nicholas started out as a giver who did not want to be seen. The list and the verdict arrived much later, in American poems and songs. If your household enjoys that half of the joke, the naughty or nice list checker on this site runs in the browser and makes up its answer, always on the generous side, and Xmas Naughty Or Nice Scanner is the louder version for the phone: it frames a face in candy-cane stripes, sweeps a light across it and announces an invented verdict on a ribbon. It examines nothing, and it is a small one-time purchase on iPhone. Save it for when the shoes are back on and the whole family is in the room.
Sources
- Ott, Michael. St. Nicholas of Myra. The Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 11, New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1911 (New Advent transcription)
- Jacobus de Voragine. The Golden Legend (c. 1275), Life of S. Nicholas the Bishop, William Caxton's English translation (1483), Internet Medieval Sourcebook, Fordham University
- The Translation of Saint Nicholas (anonymous Greek account of the removal of the relics to Bari, 1087), trans. J. McGinley and H. Musurillo, Internet Medieval Sourcebook, Fordham University
- Christian Relic of Saint Nicholas Radiocarbon Dated, Archaeology magazine, Archaeological Institute of America, December 2017
- Schoen zetten door de eeuwen heen (Putting out the shoe through the centuries), Meertens Instituut, Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences, November 2025