A small red Santa hat perched on a sprig of holly with red berries, Christmas lights blurred behind
Photo: Hert Niks / Pexels

Santa wears red because the people drawing him kept choosing red, and they started more than a century before Coca-Cola. The earliest known pictures of a Santa figure, in a New York picture book from 1821, already show him in a red coat.

So why does Santa wear red? The color came from illustrators, not from a soft drink. A colored 1821 book put him in red, the cartoonist Thomas Nast moved him from tan to red over the following decades, and Coca-Cola’s famous 1931 advertisements painted a Santa who was already red. Nobody wrote down why.

Did Coca-Cola make Santa red?

No, and the company says so itself.

Coca-Cola’s own history page on the illustrator Haddon Sundblom is plain about it. It records that the company began placing Santa advertisements by Sundblom in popular magazines in 1931, and then states that although people often say Santa wears red because red is Coca-Cola’s color, Santa appeared in a red coat before Sundblom ever painted him. It is not every day a brand turns down credit for something, which is part of why the correction is worth trusting.

What Sundblom did do was make one version of Santa extremely familiar. The company’s page says he worked from Clement Clarke Moore’s 1823 poem, used a friend, a retired salesman named Lou Prentiss, as his model, and painted his last Santa for the company in 1964. Three decades of the same warm, round, red Santa in magazines that sat on a great many American coffee tables is a strong way to fix a picture in people’s heads. Fixing a picture is a different thing from inventing it, and the myth comes from mixing the two up.

Where does the red coat actually start?

In a small paperback published in New York in 1821, two years before the poem everybody knows.

It was called The Children’s Friend, Number III, and it contains an anonymous poem that begins “Old Santeclaus with much delight.” Yale’s Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library holds a copy, and its scanned pages are available to anyone. Open the first plate and there he is: a small bearded man in a tall brown fur hat and a bright red coat, driving a sleigh across a rooftop behind a single reindeer, with a sign reading REWARDS arched over the back of his sleigh.

The library’s catalog record adds a detail we love. The full title advertises the book as “containing eight coloured engravings,” priced at 25 cents, or 18 3/4 cents plain. In other words, the red was an upgrade. Somebody colored those plates, and a family paid a little extra to get Santa in color. The earliest red Santa in print is, in a small way, a premium edition.

In that same book, the REWARDS sign on the sleigh is the start of a story we traced in the history of the naughty or nice list. This one pamphlet did an unreasonable amount of work.

What did the 1823 poem say he wore?

Fur, and soot. No color at all.

The poem first printed anonymously in the Troy Sentinel on December 23, 1823, and later credited to Moore, describes its visitor this way: “He was dress’d all in fur, from his head to his foot, / And his clothes were all tarnish’d with ashes and soot.” He has rosy cheeks, a nose like a cherry and the stump of a pipe. The reddest things about him are his face.

This matters because the 1823 poem is the text everybody later drew from, Sundblom included. It gave illustrators a jolly shape and a fur outfit and left the color entirely to them. For the next hundred years, they did not all agree.

How did Thomas Nast change Santa?

Slowly, over about thirty years, starting with a flag.

Thomas Nast drew for Harper’s Weekly, and his first Santa appeared in its January 3, 1863 issue, in the middle of the Civil War. Smithsonian Magazine describes that Santa handing out presents in a Union Army camp, wearing a jacket patterned with stars and trousers in stripes. He was, very deliberately, dressed as the flag.

Over the decades that followed, Nast kept returning to the character. The Morristown and Morris Township Library in New Jersey, which keeps a collection devoted to Nast, describes his Santa beginning as an elfish figure in a brown fur suit and growing, drawing by drawing, into the large man in the red coat. Coca-Cola’s history page tells the same story in one sentence: Nast drew Santa for about thirty years and changed the color of his coat from tan to red. Nast’s best known portrait, Merry Old Santa Claus from 1881, is the one most people picture when they picture the Victorian Santa, and Smithsonian Magazine points out it is quietly political too, with a soldier’s pack and a U.S. belt buckle hidden in plain sight.

So by the time a soft drink company hired a painter in 1931, the red coat had a hundred and ten years of history behind it.

So why red, of all colors?

This is where the trail runs out, and we would rather say so than invent the ending.

No illustrator we can find left a note explaining the choice. The usual guess is that red echoes the robes of a bishop, since the figure descends from Saint Nicholas, bishop of Myra. It is a reasonable guess. It is also only a guess, and the 1821 plate does not help it much: the man on that rooftop is wearing a fur hat and a short coat, not anything a bishop would recognize.

What we can say is what the record shows. The first colorist chose red. Nast drifted toward red over his career. Sundblom’s advertisements made red the default for most of the twentieth century. Whether each of them was following the one before, or all of them simply found that red looks right in firelight on a cold night, the documents do not tell us.

What to tell a child who asks

If a child asks why Santa wears red, the true answer is a good one: because the people who drew him liked it best, and they have been drawing him in red for more than two hundred years. The part about the extra few cents for a colored copy tends to go down well with anyone old enough to have opinions about pocket money.

If a slightly older child asks because they have started comparing notes about how any of this works, that is a different conversation, and what to say when your child asks if Santa is real covers it. The reindeer, as it happens, have their own paper trail, and Santa’s reindeer names sets out where each one comes from. So does the plate by the fireplace: why we leave cookies and milk for Santa traces that habit back as far as the records go.

One more red thing for the house this December. Xmas Naughty Or Nice Scanner frames a face in candy-cane stripes, sweeps a red line across it and announces a verdict on a ribbon, and the verdict is invented, because nothing about anybody is examined. It is the same joke Santa has been carrying in a red coat since 1821, only louder and with better lighting, and a small one-time purchase on iPhone.

Sources